Important Info

Featured Sponsor

Become an Author is a community site, we are only as good as the content our members contribute! Whether it's a one time contribution, or a monthly or quarterly article, please consider becoming an author!

Latest Comments in...

Video of Highway 101 Landslide in California
Looks like the Facebook video gets cropped when I embedded it here. You ca
San Francisco Millennium Tower Has Settled 16 Inches
Misrepresents actual foundation geometry. Photos show deep excavation to ne
New FHWA Soil Nail Manual Addresses LRFD, Hollow Bars
Good evening from Barcelona, Spain. I am witting to you because of I am le
Engineering Geologists vs Geological Engineers vs Geotechnic
Geological engineer from Spain (looking for job smiley geoengineer.martin@gmail
San Francisco Millennium Tower Has Settled 16 Inches PDF Print E-mail
Written by Randy Post   
Thursday, 04 August 2016 06:06

Millenium Tower in San Francisco, image - MLSThe residential high-rise Millennium Tower in San Francisco has settled a total of 16 inches since opening, 2 inches deferentially.  A spokesman for the tower owner blames the settlement on the excavation next door for the Transbay Transit Center, a  $2.4 billion dollar project being constructed 60 feet underground.

However, the Transbay Joint Powers Authority (Transbay) hired geotechnical firm Arup in 2010.  Their initial report indicated that the tower had already settled 10 inches by the time excavation began for the Transit center.  Arup seems to have been tasked with design, installation, and perhaps monitoring of a geotechnical monitoring program, some information on the scope is available in a 2012 presentation given by Arup available on the Transbay website.


Portion of geotechnical monitoring program, from 2012 Arup presentation

Transbay responded to the allegations in a press release on August 1, 2016.  They note that the building designers knew of the proposed excavation at the time but still elected for piles that did not extend to bedrock.  According to SFGate, the (driven?) piles extend approximately 80 feet below grade into dense sands.  The building designers predicted 6 inches of settlement over the life of the structure. Transbay spent $58 million for an 'underground buttressing system' prior to the start of excavation.  The system consists of what sounds like a secant pile wall made up of 7 foot diameter reinforced drilled shafts that are embedded into bedrock.

Soil Profile for Transbay Center - From 2012 Arup Presentation

The condos at the tower sell from $1.6 million to more than $10 million and reportedly are home to some pretty high-profile residents, including former 49ers quarterback and hall of famer Joe Montana.  With so much money riding on the line, you can bet there will be a big legal battle.  And geotechnical experts will be front and center!

View on the inside of a condo in the Millenium Tower - MLS

Hits: 3664
Comments (1)add comment

GE Reviewer said:

Misrepresents actual foundation geometry. Photos show deep excavation to near the bottom of the Colma SC sands. Presumably the 80 ft 14" PSC piles extend below to bottom of excavation to approximately 155 ft below existing grade. The building core has the piles, I am not sure what the perimeter basement walls and lower building external fascads are supported with. The excavation bracing used diagonal struts to the middle of each basement wall so access to install piles around the perimeter was poor. It will be interesting to see the real geometry of this problem..but in the meantime let the legal misrepresentation of the problems continue...
August 20, 2016
Votes: +0

Write comment

security image
Write the displayed characters